As usual, getting new processors on tests was not easy. AMD had no senior versions, so we had to test A6-3650, equipped with four nuclei of 2.6 GHz, 4 MB L2-Kash and the Radeon HD 6530D video card. He was taken into competitors equal at the price of Intel Core i3-2100. It works with only two cores, but at a frequency of 3.1 GHz. Built -in graphics – Intel HD Graphics 2000 with six streaming processors.
The test stand for both platforms was collected with two Kingston Hyperx DDR3-1666 memory slats with a volume of 2 GB each and discrete video card Radeon HD 5870. The AMD system worked on the ASUS F1A75-V Pro motherboard, the configuration with Intel on Gigabyte GA-H61N-USB3.
Friday in the forehead
The first benchmark – PCMark 05 – confirmed our fears about the weak computers of Llano. Four nuclei A6-3650 were 16% slower than two representatives of Core i3-2100. In addition, the benchmark revealed the failure of the AMD memory controller. Lost Llano and in the test 3DMark Vantage , back on 13% in the CPU column.
Render Cinebench R11.5 , optimized for multi -flow calculations, brought AMD the first victory with a gap of 3%. But in Winrar Extra cores did not help – the lag is 45%, and it is apparently to blame for this. In one -time Superpi 1.5 The newcomer lost even more – 66%. Carrowing video in Cyberlink Mediaespresso 6.5 The state of affairs did not change – the APU was again an outsider.
The situation was a little better with games. With the installed Radeon HD 5870, the newcomer significantly lags behind the competitor only in Resident Evil 5 , But in Devil May Cry 4 And Aliens vs. Predator performed almost equal.
Inside
The most interesting thing began when we removed a discrete video card from the test stand. To begin with, we note that computing blocks to the absence of a powerful fee did not respond. The difference of 1% in synthetics and applications can be attributed to the error.
But the competition of built -in graphic nuclei turned out to be exciting. In Resident Evil 5, integrated Radeon HD 6530D showed 24.6 FPS. And despite the fact that the game worked in resolution of 1680×1050 and with scheduled charts displayed at the maximum. Intel HD Graphics 2000 issued only 10.3 FPS in this test.
Similar situation with Devil May Cry 4. While Core i3-2100 reached 10.2 FPS, A6-3650 raised the bar to completely playable 29.1 frames. Compare the results on aliens vs. Predator did not work. Only the AMD nucleus, which showed 8.4 fps, can work with DX11.
As we expected, the new AMD processors were weak when working with simple applications. But Intel surpassed on the head in terms of built -in graphics. Llano is a unique device for a computer market. On these crystals, you can assemble an HTPC or entry -level gaming system. And when money appears, buy a budget video card and get an increase in FPS. How successful the concept of Fusion will be, time will tell. Now we can only say one thing: after five years, the idea has finally became a reality and really works.
The editors thanks
Oldi Computers (www.Oldi.ru) for the provided processor Intel Core i3-2100.
Table 1
Synthetic tests
PCMARK05
CPU
Intel Core i3-2100
9415
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
9537
AMD A6-3650
7968
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
7676
Memory
Intel Core i3-2100
9997
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
9831
AMD A6-3650
5475
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
5448
HDD
Intel Core i3-2100
5267
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
5341
AMD A6-3650
3543
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
4969
Performance ratio
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
101%
AMD A6-3650
84%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
82%
3DMark Vantage
GPU
Intel Core i3-2100
18 129
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
AMD A6-3650
14 895
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
2469
CPU
Intel Core i3-2100
10 133
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
AMD A6-3650
8891
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
8903
Overall
Intel Core i3-2100
15 142
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
AMD A6-3650
12 714
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
3013
Performance ratio
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
AMD A6-3650
87%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
88%
Cinebench R11.5 (64-bit)
X1
Intel Core i3-2100
1.25
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
1.27
AMD A6-3650
0.79
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
0.8
XN
Intel Core i3-2100
3.02
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
3.21
AMD A6-3650
3.11
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
3.12
Multi
Intel Core i3-2100
2.42x
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
2.52x
AMD A6-3650
3.93x
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
3.92x
Performance ratio
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
106%
AMD A6-3650
103%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
103%
Winrar (File 100 MB)
X1
Intel Core i3-2100
930 KB/s
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
914 KB/s
AMD A6-3650
618 KB/s
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
614 KB/s
AMD Athlon II X4 631
719 KB/s
XN
Intel Core i3-2100
2162 KB/s
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
2126 KB/s
AMD A6-3650
1191 KB/s
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
1390 KB/s
AMD Athlon II X4 631
1628 KB/s
Performance ratio
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
98%
AMD A6-3650
55%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
64%
AMD Athlon II X4 631
75%
Table 2
Applications
Superpi 1.5 (32 MB, Loop 10)
Time
Intel Core i3-2100
11 minutes
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
11.2 minutes
AMD A6-3650
24.9 minutes
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
24.9 minutes
Performance ratio
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
98%
AMD A6-3650
44%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
44%
Cyberlink Mediaespresso 6.5 (1080p (150 MB) in Apple 720p)
Time
Intel Core i3-2100
1.56 minutes
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
1.58 minutes
AMD A6-3650
1.98 minutes
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
1.97 minutes
Performance ratio
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
99%
AMD A6-3650
79%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
79%
Table 3
Game tests (personnel per second)
Resident Evil 5 (DX10)
High, 1680×1050
Intel Core i3-2100
93.9
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
10.3
AMD A6-3650
67.6
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
25.8
High, 1920×1080
Intel Core i3-2100
92.7
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
9.6
AMD A6-3650
66.8
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
21.8
Performance ratio
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
11%
AMD A6-3650
72%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
25%
Devil May Cry 4 (DX10)
Veryhigh, 1680×1050
Intel Core i3-2100
175.8
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
10.2
AMD A6-3650
179.2
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
29.1
VERYHIGH, 1920×1080
Intel Core i3-2100
163
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
8.9
AMD A6-3650
163.3
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
25.5
Performance ratio
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
5%
AMD A6-3650
101%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
16%
Aliens vs. Predator (DX11)
Veryhigh, 1680×1050
Intel Core i3-2100
67.7
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
–
AMD A6-3650
64.3
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
8.4
VERYHIGH, 1920×1080
Intel Core i3-2100
60.6
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
–
AMD A6-3650
57.6
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
7.4
Performance ratio
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
–
AMD A6-3650
95%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
12%
Table 4
Price/performance ratio
Synthetic tests
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
101%
AMD A6-3650
82%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
84%
Applications
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
98%
AMD A6-3650
61%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
61%
Games
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
AMD A6-3650
89%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
18%
General performance
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
99%
AMD A6-3650
77%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
54%
Price
Intel Core i3-2100
100%
Intel Core i3-2100 + HD Graphics
100%
AMD A6-3650
100%
AMD A6-3650 + Radeon HD 6530D
100%
Deja una respuesta